VoyForums
[ Show ]
Support VoyForums
[ Shrink ]
VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Main index ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1 ]

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Date Posted: 01:05:58 01/01/02 Tue
Author: 西贡古琴
Subject: 媒体是如何公平对待赵薇的 (REPOST BY JUNE)

版权所有：西贡古琴 原作　提交时间：16:48:27 12月31日

作为一名旁观者，我本抱着看热闹的心态看这场闹剧的，但现在事态的发展已脱离了理智的范畴。现在我给大家回顾以下新浪是如何一步步把赵薇推向深渊的。
第一步：网友发赵薇服装照片，新浪质疑：“赵薇服装象日本军旗？”
点评：媒体正常炒作，无可厚非。
第二步：“军旅作家，历史学家说赵薇穿的就是日本军旗“。
点评：随便找了两个证人就主观臆定，等于法庭在辩护律师缺席的情况下给人定罪。
第三步：“网友申讨赵薇“、
点评：以偏概全。用部分网友的声音代表所有网友的身声音以扩大舆论影响。
第四步：“南京大屠杀幸存者要求赵薇道歉“
点评：错误的舆论导向导致的必然后果。
第五步：“赵薇老家被砸“
点评：明知是传言还发布，其实是暗示人们去采取类似行动。
第六步：赵薇道歉后，“历史学家说赵薇道歉已太晚“
点评：那还要赵薇怎么办，有这样的宣传后来出现对赵薇的极端行动就不难理解了。
第七步：赵薇被打后新浪快讯说：“现场有叫好声”。后来证实现场绝无此事。
点评：那叫好的是谁呢？
第八步：这两天的新浪首页上有对赵薇被打事件的民意调查，竟然有对打人者表示支持这一选项，并列在首位。
点评：打人本来就不对，新浪竟还在为打人者去赢得支持。

总点评：媒体暴力在中国已浮出水面！

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:

[> Translation: -- Mina (Canada), 09:41:36 01/01/02 Tue

Author: See Chun Ko Ching
Date Posted: Dec 31, 2001

How the media treats ZhaoWei (since the "Japanese Military Flag Outfit incident")

I was at first just an outsider, going with the flow and watching the whole incident as a soap opera. But now, with the "Concert Attack incident", things have developed to a stage which is out of rationality. Now let me do a recap of how Sina has pushed ZhaoWei to the current awkward situation.
Step 1:
A posting by websurfer in Sina of Vicki's picture with the Japanese Military Flag Outfit. Then Sina released a report questioning : "ZhaoWei's outfit looks like the Japanese Military Flag"
My (Writer of this article) comment: It's simply a media trying to create news. Not unusual.
Step 2:
Sina's another report quoting : "Writers from the army and historians confirmed that ZhaoWei's outfit is the Japanese Military Flag."
My comment: Casually and subjectively made a conclusion based on the view of several "witnesses". This is no difference than confirming a case to be a crime without the presence of the defensive attorney.
Step 3:
Sina reporting: "Websurfers denounce ZhaoWei".
My comment: Represent the views of ALL websurfers with that of just some to show how big the influence of the media (
Sina) is.
Step 4:
Sina reporting: "Those who survive the Najing massacre ask for ZhaoWei's apology."
My comment: The unavoidable consequence resulted from misleading reports.
Step 5:
Sina reporting: "ZhaoWei's home in Hunan got attacked."
My comment: (Sina) Still reporting on this though knowing so clearly this is just rumor. It's (Sina's) real intention is to incinerate people to carry out such act.
Step 6:
Sina reporting: "After ZhaoWei apologized, historians think it's too late."
My comment: What more do they want from ZhaoWei? With this report, it's not hard to predict (or understand) the extreme things done to ZhaoWei afterwards (the "Concert Attack incident").
Step 7:
Sina reporting, after ZhaoWei got attacked: "Cheers were heard on the concert site (after ZhaoWei got beaten up)." But from witnesses and audiences on site, there is NO such thing as people cheering.
My comment: Who's the one that is really cheering?
Step 8:
These few days, there is a survey conducted by Sina on how people think of the incidence of ZhaoWei got beaten up. Surprisingly, Sina put up a choice of "Support that man (who attacked ZhaoWei)" AND this choice got the
majority of the votes.
My comment: It's already wrong to beat people up. But Sina is helping the man who is doing such a wrong thing to gain support.

Overall Comment: "Media Violence" is gradually exposing itself in China!


[ Edit | View ]

[> 叫好的是新浪。 -- xiaxin, 03:30:00 01/03/02 Thu

第七步：赵薇被打后新浪快讯说：“现场有叫好声”。后来证实现场绝无此事。
点评：那叫好的是谁呢？
叫好的是新浪。


[ Edit | View ]


Forum timezone: GMT+8
VF Version: 3.00b, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2019 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.