VoyForums

VoyUser Login optional ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1 ]


[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Date Posted: 01:19:51 01/24/07 Wed
Author: priya (love)
Subject: Re: Attack on Christians in India
In reply to: Joseph N Raju 's message, "Re: Attack on Christians in India" on 06:18:49 03/16/04 Tue

>>The US (INS) needs to curb the entry of Hindu
>>preachers into the country.
>>India has recently asked a US missionary, who was
>>brutally attacked by Hindu fundamentalists and under
>>treatement to heal his severed hand, to leave the
>>country immediately.
>>The reason given is, he preached while on visitor
>visa!
>>
>>
>>http://indiancurrents.com/ic4/mukundan.htm
>>
>>Missionary Blood on their Hands
>>
>>A Gujarat Model in Kerala
>>
>>-- Mukundan C. Menon
>>
>>I have no ill will or hatred against my attackers. I
>>would be glad to invite them for a lunch, instead. Of
>>course, initially I was angry. But, later I realized
>>that whatever had happened was according to God’s
>>will", said Pennsylvania-based U.S. missionary, Bishop
>>Joseph W. Cooper (67), while convalescing at Kerala
>>Institute of Medical Science (KIMS) hospital in
>>Thiruvananthapuram, a day after he was attacked
>>reportedly by RSS activists on January 13 night at
>>Koppam near Kilimannor in Thiruvananthapuram district
>>of Kerala. He had gone there to attend a Gospel
>>Convention at Friends of Bible Church.
>>
>>His right hand, nearly chopped off, was rejoined in an
>>operation. There were other minor injuries and he was
>>still writhing in pain when he talked to the stream of
>>people who made a beeline to the hospital this past
>>week-end. Among the visitors were top leaders of both
>>the ruling United Democratic Front (UDF) and
>>opposition Left Democratic Front (LDF). According to
>>KIMS doctors, who operated upon him, he was out of
>>danger but may have to remain in hospital for another
>>fortnight or so.
>>
>>There was wide condemnation of the dastardly attack
>>from within and outside Kerala and India. All
>>right-thinking people opined in unison that this
>>should not have ever happened in Kerala. Not because
>>45 percent of the State population belong to the
>>minority Muslim and Christian communities. Not because
>>Christian and Muslim parties are ruling UDF partners.
>>But because Kerala has a proud and exemplary history
>>of communal amity, to where both Christianity and
>>Islam reached at the same time it spread respectively
>>in Europe 2000 years ago and in Arab peninsula 1,400
>>years ago. Also, because, Kerala is not Orissa, where
>>the Australian missionary Graham Steins and his two
>>kids were brutally burnt alive by Hindutva forces
>>three years ago, and surely not Gujarat which
>>witnessed the ethnic cleansing of Muslims last year
>>under the aegis of ruling Moditva forces. Keralites
>>also co-existed with Jews, Arabs, Portuguese, Dutch,
>>and the British, which is an unenviable and unparallel
>>history from rest of India. Malayalees also maintain
>>the exceptional inborn nature of going anywhere in the
>>world and settling there by easily getting mingled
>>with the local populace.
>>
>>Notably, the January 13 attack on Cooper and other
>>missionaries came within weeks after President Dr. A.
>>P. J. Kalam inaugurated the 1950th anniversary of the
>>arrival of St. Thomas to Kerala at massive convention
>>of Christians at Kochi last month. The attack took
>>place five days before the Kerala Government’s
>>prestigious Global Investment Meet (GIM) to be held at
>>Kochi on January 18-19, which was to be attended by
>>major foreign investor delegates from USA, Europe and
>>Middle-East region. It also came a week before the
>>International Pentecostal Convention to be held at
>>Kumbanad near Thiruvalla in which around 100,000
>>believers and 3,000 pastors from various countries are
>>scheduled to attend. And, more significantly, the
>>Sangh Parivar onslaught was carried out when top RSS
>>functionaries like RSS Sarsanghchalak, K. S.
>>Sudarshan, and Akhil Bharatiya Vanavasi Kalyan Ashram
>>president, Jagadev Ram Orone, was in Kerala making
>>wanton statements on conversions and foreign
>>missionaries. The attack took place amidst the Sangh
>>Parivar leaders taking strong exceptions to President
>>Dr. Kalam accepting the invitation to attend a jubilee
>>function of Jesuits to be held at Calcutta soon. The
>>incident, therefore, cannot be treated either as a
>>coincidence or isolated case, although Chief Minister
>>A. K. Antony wanted the world to believe so in an
>>apparent attempt to dilute its seriousness on the eve
>>of the GIM.
>>
>>In the post-Cabinet meet press briefing on January 15,
>>Mr. Antony termed the attack as an "isolated incident"
>>and said : "Such incidents are very unfortunate and
>>should not take place". He pleaded ignorance as to who
>>the attackers were. "I directed the police to conduct
>>a thorough investigation of the incident. I am
>>following this up and at the moment I have nothing
>>more to say", he added. Antony’s ignorance should be
>>read along with his holding charge of police (Home)
>>portfolio and that the police have already arrested
>>one known RSS local leader, Raju, and took into
>>custody four others (Shaji, his brother Shan and
>>Shaiju) for questioning. The Kilimanoor police
>>registered a case under IPC 307 (attempt to murder)
>>and other counts under Explosives Act and Rioting,
>>since the attack took place after throwing of bombs.
>>"Although it is known to all that the attack was
>>carried out by the RSS, why Antony is scared of
>>uttering these three letters", questioned CPI-M State
>>Secretary Pinarayi Vijayan. According to CPI State
>>Secretary, Veliyam Bhargavan, "the Sangh Parivar is
>>trying to repeat in Kerala their agenda of
>>intimidating and attacking Christian missionaries in
>>Gujarat and Orissa".
>>
>>Bishop Cooper was attacked along with the local
>>preacher, Pastor Benson K. Sam (37), his wife Sali
>>Benson, their two children (Joy and Judith), singers
>>Jayakumar and Mercy Christudas, of whom Pastor Sam
>>also suffered serious injuries. The colony settlers
>>are "Vedars", a Dalit community, with 60-odd houses
>>and around 150 population, who follow both Christian
>>and Hindu faiths. With no conversion in recent past,
>>some of the Vedars’ forefathers had converted into
>>Christianity. Although the January 13 attackers belong
>>to nearby area and are known Sangh Parivar activists,
>>the area witnessed total communal harmony until a bomb
>>exploded in a nearby school three days before the
>>attack took place.
>>
>>Those attended the Bible Convention are still at a
>>loss to grasp as to what provoked the RSS men to carry
>>out the attack. Surely there was no provocation from
>>us, they said. According to one source, two RSS
>>activists, auto-driver Kumar and the owner of
>>upholstery shop at Kilimanoor, Shaji, came to the
>>venue of the Convention and asked the mike operator
>>whether the public address system belonged to the US
>>missionary and left the place. Later two or three
>>unidentified people came to the venue, stayed around
>>for some time listening to the Bible speeches. Even
>>then there was no hint of the impending attack.
>>
>>The gruesome incident took place after the convention
>>ended at 9.30 p.m. and when Bishop Cooper, Benson and
>>others were walking along the narrow path to where
>>their vehicles were parked. The vehicle tiers were
>>deflated in advance by the attackers to ensure that
>>the missionaries won’t get away. The Bible hall was
>>situated on a high range amid rubber plantation, and
>>the vehicles were parked below on the road.
>>
>>The gang, comprising more than a dozen people and
>>waiting in the rubber plantation, suddenly pounced
>>upon the missionaries by throwing country bombs to
>>create scare and started attacking with knives and
>>swords. While Cooper’s right hand was nearly chopped
>>off, Benson had a head injury, and his wife and
>>daughter were left unconscious on the spot.
>>
>>The terrified local people did not come forward to
>>rush them to the hospital, until the police reached
>>the spot after half-hour. According to Pastor Benson,
>>there were no electric lamp posts in the area and they
>>were approaching the car, 150 metres away, with the
>>help of torch-light when the unexpected attack took
>>place. The main target of the attackers was Rev.
>>Cooper. They detained the missionary and other
>>preachers for some time before attacking them with
>>swords, crowbars and knives.
>>
>>Pastor Benson told the police that the attack was
>>carried out by known RSS activists in the area and
>>named some of them, including the auto-driver.
>>Confirming Kilimanoor Circle Inspector D. Rajagopal’s
>>version that the area had no history of communal
>>discord, He said: "There had been no threat whatsoever
>>to the functioning of the church in the area so far".
>>According to him and the police, the church was
>>constructed in the area three years ago and "Gospel
>>Conventions" were held in the past as well.
>>
>>Pastor Benson further stated: "We were told that the
>>attackers were listeners at the Convention and they
>>were all armed. Before the attack started, a
>>country-made bomb exploded just inches away from me."
>>Lizzy, a colony resident narrated their plight: "Most
>>of us eke out our livelihood through manual labour. We
>>are totally neglected by the Government and
>>politicians. Being converted Christians, we are denied
>>reservation benefits. In this grim situation, we rest
>>our hopes only on God and decided to hold the Bible
>>Convention". Despite electric lines were taken through
>>the colony to a nearby locality four years ago and
>>promise of power connections given to them, the
>>"Vedars" colony still has no electricity. Plugs,
>>switches and other electric materials that they
>>purchased long ago lie unused. Neither do they have
>>pure drinking water in the colony. Following the
>>attack, although all the politicians expressed grave
>>concern on the incident and showered promises on
>>communal amity, people in the colony no more trust
>>their promises on upliftment of socio-economic
>>conditions from their own hard and bitter past
>>experience.
>>
>>A senior police officer said : "This is the first
>>organized attack on a foreign missionary in Kerala,
>>whose one-third population are Christians". According
>>to Pastor Benson, "it was a silent attack since the
>>assailants did not utter a single word even though we
>>pleaded them to reveal their motive". ‘’We could
>>identify most of the members of the ten-member gang.
>>All of them are known RSS activists in the locality
>>and we have mentioned this in the police complaint,’’
>>he added.
>>
>>Bishop Cooper has been a missionary for the past 25
>>years and this was the first time he has been attacked
>>anywhere in the world. This was his 12th visit to
>>Kerala, "which is a great place with fantastic people,
>>except what happened to me which is not good for the
>>State’s reputation."
>>
>>He was a professional parachute jumper in his young
>>days. He entered missionary work in early 1970s as an
>>energetic youth and after resigning job from a
>>professional firm. Since then, he has been actively
>>involved in evangelization in many countries. He
>>reached India for the current tour early this month to
>>attend a series of gospel conventions in Kerala, Goa
>>and Andhra Pradesh. He was scheduled to leave for
>>Visakhapatnam on Tuesday but, instead, landed in the
>>intensive care unit at KIMS. "This is not going to
>>deter my spirits and I will certainly be back in
>>Kerala. I am happy that I was able to speak to my wife
>>and my close friends who appeared tensed after hearing
>>what happened", Rev. Cooper said. He added: "I’ve
>>forgiven my attackers. Now that the case has been
>>registered, I do not know if there is a provision by
>>which I can withdraw it. In the U.S., one could sue
>>for damages, but I am not going to do any such thing."
>>
>>Expressing shock and concern over the attack, a US
>>embassy spokesperson in New Delhi said : "This is a
>>very serious matter. You cannot just go on attacking
>>anybody. Naturally we are deeply concerned". The
>>United States condemned the attack and a State
>>Department official in Washington said that
>>authorities were in touch with the consulate in
>>Chennai. US consulate officials from Chennai are
>>reaching Kerala to ascertain the facts relating to the
>>attack. They already had a telephonic discussion with
>>Cooper on Jan. 17 night.
>>
>>Expressing deep concern and pain on the attack,
>>Cardinal Varkey Vithayathil, Major Archbishop of
>>Syro-Malabar Church, said it was ominous to see
>>certain groups resorting to violence to settle any
>>difference of opinion in a democratic country.
>>"Unfortunately these violent elements have been
>>emboldened by the rhetoric of certain fundamentalist
>>leaders of Hindutva, who spread hatred against
>>minorities. Fundamentalism was consistently destroying
>>the religious and democratic foundations of this
>>country. The attack is a sad betrayal of the country’s
>>heritage of welcoming a guest as God himself into our
>>midst", Vithayathil, who is also the Chairman of
>>Kerala Catholic Bishops Council, said.
>>
>>Meanwhile, the Kerala State Human Rights Commission,
>>which took suo motto cognizance of the issue, sought a
>>report from Thiruvananthapuram (Rural) Superintendent
>>of Police to be submitted within 15 days.
>>
>>RSS operation cover-up
>>
>>No sooner the widely condemned dastardly act took
>>place, the entire lobby of Sangh Parivar plunged into
>>action with their customary leveling of baseless
>>accusations, wild allegations, and unsubstantiated
>>charges against Rev. Cooper and the evangelist
>>missionaries. Panic and fear prevailed in and around
>>Kilimanoor after the Sangh Parivar undertook a
>>procession within 24 hours of the attack accusing the
>>police of harassing "innocents" by conducting raids
>>and arrests. RSS Malayalam organ, "Janmabhoomi", said
>>that two of the evangelists were earlier involved in a
>>sex racket, and that a woman resisted their sexual
>>advances which led the "local people" to "protest
>>against the missionaries" on January 13 at the Bible
>>Convention!
>>
>>In the first statement, the RSS "Vibhagh
>>Sahakaryavah", K. Rajasekharan, alleged that Sangh
>>workers were "falsely implicated" in the case and
>>termed the incident as "shrouded in mystery". He fired
>>the first salvo against Rev. Cooper: "It was unlawful
>>on the part of Cooper, who was on a visiting visa, to
>>preach religion in India. There should be an inquiry
>>into the circumstances under which the U.S. citizen on
>>a visiting visa was allowed to speak at a Gospel
>>Convention." Sangh Parivar leaders also alleged that
>>Rev. Cooper and other preachers at the Convention made
>>"inflammatory and insulting speeches" against Hindus,
>>which was stoutly denied by all those who attended the
>>convention, including Pastor Benson.
>>
>>On January 27, VHP Kerala unit demanded the "arrest
>>and prosecution" of Rev. Cooper for alleged violation
>>of Foreigners’ Act. The VHP State Organising
>>Secretary, Kummanam Rajasekharan, asked the State
>>Government to initiate prosecution proceedings against
>>Rev. Cooper for "carrying out religious propaganda
>>after coming to the country on a visiting visa". He
>>claimed that "as per the Foreigners Act of 1956,
>>foreigners visiting the country should not engage
>>themselves in religious preaching and are only
>>supposed to do sight-seeing and visit relatives".
>>Besides, Rev.Cooper and his team of evangelists
>>"slandered" the Hindu "dharma" and traditions and
>>sought to convert the residents of a Scheduled Caste
>>colony by allurement and compulsory means, the VHP
>>leader alleged. The Kilimanoor incident, according to
>>the VHP leader, "underlined the need for a code of
>>conduct for missionary activities".
>>
>>While Sangh Parivar is taking the opportunity to
>>demand introduction of an Act banning "forcible
>>conversion", they are left without answers as to how
>>people like Mata Amrithanandamayi are frequently
>>visiting Western countries for preaching religion and
>>how her "Ashram" at Vallikavu, near Kollam, has a
>>large number of Western devotees. In fact, a French
>>lady in the Ashram died under mysterious circumstances
>>in August last year. "What will be their reaction in
>>India if any such attack took place on
>>Amrithanandamayi abroad", reacted an evangelist in his
>>reaction given to a Malayalam TV channel.
>>
>>Notably, inflammatory statements, if any, in Kerala
>>had come from people like RSS chief Sudarshan before
>>and after the attack on Rev. Cooper. On the day of the
>>attack, Akhil Bharatiya Vanavasi Kalyan Ashram
>>president, Jagdevram Oraon, told a press conference at
>>Kozhicode: "West-promoted conversions into
>>Christianity were causing divisiveness among the
>>people in the country. Countries like the United
>>States and Britain were creating their own pockets
>>through missionaries. Issues like ‘Nagas’, causing
>>divisions in the country, are a consequence of this.
>>The foreign churches through conversions made the
>>tribals isolated from the mainstream of the society".
>>
>>The day after the attack on Rev. Cooper, the RSS
>>chief, while inaugurating the Akhila Kerala Vanavasi
>>Sangamam, at Wayanad said : "Even Mahatmaji had
>>cautioned against weaning Hindus. The British had
>>invented many theories like the Aryan invasion to
>>divide the Hindus. Though the theory has logical
>>validity, it was used to create schism within the
>>community. The Arya-Dravida, Brahmin-non-Brahmin,
>>North India-South India divisions are the by-products
>>of the theory."

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

VoyUser Login ] Not required to post.
Post a public reply to this message | Go post a new public message
* Notice: Posting problems? [ Click here ]
* HTML allowed in marked fields.
Message subject (required):

Name (required):

  Expression (Optional mood/title along with your name) Examples: (happy, sad, The Joyful, etc.) help)

  E-mail address (optional):

* Type your message here:


Notice: Copies of your message may remain on this and other systems on internet. Please be respectful.

[ Contact Forum Admin ]


Forum timezone: GMT-8
VF Version: 2.94, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2008 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.