Date Posted:Tue, Jan 24 2006, 10:11:44 PST Author:Buddy Author Host/IP: dialup-4.156.108.115.Dial1.Boston1.Level3.net / 4.156.108.115 Subject: Re: Walking Stick Form In reply to:
PD
's message, "Re: Walking Stick Form" on Mon, Jan 09 2006, 5:18:56 PST
PD,
I'm not fond of replying to someone who remains anonymous but I didn't mention anything about the short stick. Rather it was a staff form. Perhaps if you re-read my post.
"I would be interested in hearing about Luo Dexiu's take on Wang's taiji, though I would certainly not consider Luo's practice of CPL's taiji to be in any way representative of the style. Since he's a superb martial artist it would nonetheless be interesting to hear his opinion."
And when have you ever seen Luo do taiji? It's not something he shows very often.
"What I do wonder, and I'm sure others do too, is where YOUR obsession with the question of the origin of Wang's neijiaquan comes from. Perhaps you'd care to share that too?"
Well this is a strawman question. Where in my post do you glean this from?
"Above all, why don't we all promote some real research into these issues, instead of relying on hearsay and guesses. If we genuinely started looking into these things, I'm pretty sure we'd find something closer to the truth than what we have to day.That is if they are even worth looking into..."
I have no idea what your trying to say.
OTOH, is there anymore information about when Mr. Chen is coming tho the US?
