| Subject: Re: Lot's of theories: Voldemort, Rookwood, Gryffindor's Heir, and Lethifolds |
Author:
sarah
|
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
Date Posted: 19:34:25 03/01/02 Fri
In reply to:
KioRustleweed
's message, "Lot's of theories: Voldemort, Rookwood, Gryffindor's Heir, and Lethifolds" on 07:56:33 12/16/01 Sun
Wow that was really great, I must say. You really have some neat ideas. Do you really think that the time turner had anything to do with the whole/Lily/Unspeakable idea? (which was brilliant , just to tell you) I can totally get behind the idea that lily was an unspeakable, but why would the time turner would play a part in it?
I also have another question - What did you mean by Gryffindor's Heir? Are you saying that Harry would be of decent from Godric Gryffindor himself? If you are saying that, i agree. Thats kind of stretching it a bit far, isnt it?
please write back to me,
Sarah Masters
>Hi. I've written a very long post compliling a lot of
>my ideas, theories and reactions to some of the rumors
>floating around the internet. I've been posting these
>on a lot of message boards across the internet to see
>what people think. If you want to contact me, my email
>is kio9528@cs.com. I might not have a chance to reply
>to any posts, but i hope you'll find this intersting,
>in the least. Watch out.
>
>
>Augustus Rookwood and the Department of Mysteries. The
>significance of the character is not always
>recognizable because he is very minor, but I predict
>he is very impotant. In Book 4, while Harry is
>dallying in Dumbledore's thoughts in the Pensieve, he
>sees the trial Karkaroff, who proceeds to name Death
>eaters. However the only undiscovered name he gives is
>Rookwood, who used an intricate net of wizards in the
>Ministry to pass information to Oldy Voldy.
>
>While this fact may seem insignificant at first, you
>shoudl examine the idea of Rowling even mentioning the
>Department of Mysteries in the first place. We know
>absolutley nothing, but I bet we will find out a lot
>more about it in future books. In fact, I'd wager that
>Lily Potter was an Unspeakable before she was murdered
>and that it was some connection to her job that led
>the whole fiasco of the their murders. If this is
>true, it opens worlds of possibilities, not only about
>the function of the Deparment of Mysteries (could it
>be time travel? the Time turner reappears?) but it's
>connection to Harry also, because we know Voldemort
>didn't go to Godric's Hollow to kill Lily. Voldy could
>have gone to kill Harry because of the information he
>obtained from Rookwood. And then, of course, comes the
>question: What is the Order of the Pheonix in the
>first place? Does it have something to do with this
>Department? after all, we're supposed to have a huge
>revelation about Lily.
>
>Another thing that could be connected to the
>Department of Mysteries is Trelawney's first
>prediction. If the Department of Mysteries deal with
>"true" Seers, or at least "true" predictions. Maybe
>then, Lily might be a Seer, although I will admit, its
>very far-fetched.
>
>As for the theory of Harry being Gryffindor's heir: It
>makes sense. In fact the evidence is overwhelming,
>there is so much in favor of this theory that it makes
>me uncomfortable. I want to disbelieve this theory
>because not only is it totaly predictable, I have
>faith in JK to invent something more important, more
>significant than the contiued bloodline of the heirs.
>After all, isn't one of the reoccuring themes in the
>books all about the unimportance of blood, whether
>pure or muggle-born? But then you get Dumbledore's
>gleam of triumph at the use of Harry's blood in
>Voldy's resurection, but that's going completely off
>track.....
>
>The main point I'm trying to make, and I'm depending
>heavily on one piece of information I read in an
>interview, is that JK will not make Harry Heir of
>Gryffindor. What I mean is, JK said that she goes
>online sometimes and reads some of the theories and
>rumors. She said she's surprised at the creativity of
>fans, but she said that no one has guessed what will
>happen yet. And quite a few people have guessed that
>Harry's the heir.
>
>Besides I'd like to think that Harry is as cool as he
>is because of his own ability, not because of some
>inheirited blood.
>
>On a side note, one of the main reasons I argue
>against Gryffindor's heir is the murder of James and
>Lily itself. We all know that Lily needn't have died,
>but what about james? It never says specifically
>whther Voldy was after James too. Nowhere in any of
>the books did it say that Voldemort's intentions were
>to murder James too. It says that he fought Voldemort,
>therefore he had to die. But isn't this just another
>form of getting in the way? Lily was in the way, so
>she died. James was trying to protect his family also,
>and he died. It did NOT say anything about James
>needing to be killed. Of course it doesn't say that
>Voldy didn't not need to kill James.... but I believe
>that James' death was also uneccessary.
>
>I wish Dumbledore would hurry up and tell us why Voldy
>wanted to kill Harry in the first place, he obviously
>knows!
>
>Another thing you might like to know. JK said in
>another interview that cats were something important.
>Or rather, one person asked a question about how many
>cats are in the HP books and whther or not they
>provide some sort of protection. Jk said something to
>the effect that there might be, and that
>question-asker was very observant.
> And the cats are: Crookshanks (part Kneazle,
>obviously), Mrs. Norris, Prof. McGonagall, and Mrs.
>Figg's cats! Can you imagine? At midnight, everynight
>Mrs. Figg makes her cats invisble and has them circle
>the Dursley's house continuosly, meowing in unision...
>well, okay, not really, but I would laugh if it were
>true. I don't think that Mrs. Figg was their secret
>Keeper, because she'd have to do the charm every
>summer, and it just doesn't make very good sense, at
>least, I don't think we can speculate on that until we
>know more about how the Fidelius Charm works.. But the
>cats...ahhh, the cats. Maybe..
>
>Oh, and one last thing. I am quite convinced that
>Harry will meet a Lethifold. If you reread Magical
>Beast and where To Find Them, you will remember that
>the Lethifold is only repelled by the Patronus Charm,
>which we all know Harry is expert at. It also seems
>like the sort of animal Voldy would use to help him
>gain powers. I bet that you could capture a Lethifold,
>even if you couldn't domesticate it. It would be an
>interesting challenge for Harry, anyway.
>
>Sorry so long. any ideas?
>
>Kio Rustleweed
>www.geocities.com/harrypottertrivia
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
| |
Feedback: 