Re: topic 3 -- Early World History, Level I

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1 ]

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Date Posted: 12:39:10 03/08/02 Fri
Author: THE Tim Carson
Subject: Re: topic 3
In reply to: j curboy 's message, "topic 3" on 05:21:40 02/26/02 Tue

Rome lasted for so long because it was unchallenged by any other civilization. It was unchallenged, it had the strongest military, culture, and government. At Rome's peak which was a great one, it might have been assumed that they would rule as the most influential civilization forever, however, they didn't. Rome eventually fell for many reasons. Since Rome was the strongest country, its leader must have been very strong and important. The power the emperor had was infinite. So many people wanted to be in that position, they cheated, killed, lied, and were forced to be evil and competitive to get what they wanted, which was the most powerful position in the world. The key word is "power". Rome gained so much power, it slowly destroyed itself because its citizens became dishonest and power-hungry. People would break laws to get what they wanted, and if laws are broken, the government becomes essentially powerless. Rome's destruction came from within itself, not from another culture conquering it. This is the very reason that eutopian societies do not function well for a long time. People are ambitious and want to excel in life. Modern dictatorships, like Iraq and Cuba, who appoint one person in charge of both the government and military, are sure for eventual disaster because that is too much power to keep balanced. Thankfully, they do not issue the dictator of those countries religious power as well. However, political and military influence are plenty to desroy a nation. This allows the dictator to justify military violence with polotics, and to pass laws because people are scared of the military and are afraid to object. Today, these countries are ignored as far as trade, and although they seem to be functioning well, in maybe ten or twenty years, they will eventually fall, because, after all, power corrupts...:)

Love,

Tim

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:

[> Re: topic 3 -- Tom O'Brien, 12:40:55 03/08/02 Fri

>Every civilization to come down the pike has visions
>of lasting for a thousand years. This is especially
>true of the Romans. Investigate why the romans were
>so successful for so long and what finally caused
>their downfall. Compare this to any more modern
>culture to see if there are any reasons why the more
>modern civilizations are not able to LAST. Use
>specifics when making your arguement.

The Roman Empire was one of the most powerful, respected and long lasting civilizations to ever exists. I believe there were many reasons that enabled the Romans to last for such a long time. Several of theses reasons included their powerful yet disciplined army, their extremely well organized government and the people of the empire. Several reasons that led to the downfall of Rome were its inability to stop the Teutonics from invading Rome, slavery and heavy taxes. A modern day society that can be compared to the Romans is the French.
The first reason why the Romans lasted as long as they did is because of their extremely powerful army. This army enabled them to conquer practically whoever they wanted. Not only would they conquer a civilization they would destroy it so that there was no possible way for the civilization to rebuild. One example of this is the Punic Wars in which the Romans destroyed Carthage. After the first two Punic Wars the Romans had sufficiently beaten their opponents. However that was not enough for them. They started the Third Punic War in order to completely destroy Carthage. This enabled the Romans to take control of the entire Mediterranean area. Also since the Romans made it impossible for civilizations to rebuild they were forced to join the Romans, which added more civilians, which lead to a bigger army. If the Romans had not have had such a powerful army I do not believe they would have lasted as long as they could. Another thing that helped Rome last was its extremely well organized government. At first their were two social classes in Rome, Patricians and Plebians. The Patricians were the richer of the two. The Patricians ran the government while the Plebians performed other essentials. Even though more groups were added and the system was changed I believe that having these two groups with their own separate jobs helped Rome tremendously. Even though later others were aloud to govern the Patricians created a government for Rome that was extremely well thought out and efficient. If Rome had not of had this type of government I do not believe that there is any chance of it surviving one thousand years. One more thing that helped the Romans last for so long was the citizens of the empire. These citizens did not have the same principles that we have now, this helped them last for so long. For example is the Romans did not like someone or saw someone as a threat they would kill them before they had a chance to act. Nowadays this type of action would be frowned upon. However killing someone before they have a chance to act against definitely helped the Romans survive as long as they did. If the people back then had seen this as incorrect then it would not have continued and Roman would have fell sooner.
One cause of the Roman downfall was their inability to stop foreign armies from invading their empire. If the Roman army had been able to stop foreign armies near the end of their civilization then the Roman Empire would not have been taken over. This would definitely have prolonged their civilization. Another thing that caused the downfall of the Romans was slavery. When slaves arrived in the Roman Empire big farms and factories were created. Thus putting the individually owned business out of business. The civilians who were formally hard at work during the day were now board out of their minds. Now that everyone was board all day long they lost all their morals about what is right and what is wrong. Thus leading Rome to its decline.
A modern day civilization that can be compared to Rome is the French. Back in the time of the Revolutionary war the French owned much of America. However the lost most of it to the Britains and the United States during the French and Indian War and the Revolutionary War. If the French army had been able to fend of either of these two countries then there would have been a better chance of the French controlling more of America. Since this did not happen the French were only given a piece of America and finally they were completely kicked out of America.
In conclusion, several things that enabled the Roman Empire to last so long was its army, its government and the morals of its people. Also several things that led to the downfall of Rome was its inability to keep foreign invaders out of Rome, slavery and high taxes. Also a modern day civilization that Rome can be compared to is France.

[ Post a Reply to This Message ]
[ Edit | View ]