Create a New Forum Admin Login Member Login Contribute to Voyager Search VoyForums Help Desk VoyForums Exchange VoyForums Directory/Categories VoyForums Homepage VoyForums News FAQ - Frequently Asked Questions

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ]

• I'm seeing the starting AFL quite a bit differently -- Rocket surgeon, 21:14 15/12/24 Sun
  • It also all hinges on availability. (NT) -- Annabelle, 21:31 15/12/24 Sun
    • I would have WHE on a wing and Houston or Crisp. Sidey & Lipinski on margins -- Flumpus, 14:55 18/12/24 Wed
      • WHE has not been training with the mids, forwardline only. Seems his wing days are behind him (NT) -- Jen2310, 15:31 19/12/24 Thu
        • Not sure i can see him getting a game as a forward... (NT) -- collingwoodj, 10:36 22/12/24 Sun
          • Then he may be the odd one out then. Lets see post xmas -- Jen2310, 17:36 22/12/24 Sun
      • If Markov gets more than 5 or 6 games in 2025 -- Rocket surgeon, 13:05 20/12/24 Fri
        • I reckon he provides a real POD with his speed. Some drive from defence (NT) -- Flumpus, 17:52 20/12/24 Fri
          • Houston and Perryman add more drive (NT) -- Rocket surgeon, 20:50 20/12/24 Fri
            • No way he is in front of any of Bruz, Q, Josh, Houston, Perryman or Crisp -- collingwoodj, 13:02 21/12/24 Sat
        • Markov was terrible this year .. imo .. I agree (NT) -- Pendles Boys, 21:04 21/12/24 Sat
          • He was very good for them bulk of 2024. Wasn't convinced by him early, but proved very handy (NT) -- Flumpus, 05:57 22/12/24 Sun
            • Correction, 2023 (NT) -- Flumpus, 05:58 22/12/24 Sun
  • quick wings are so 80s and 90s... -- Mark W, 09:25 16/12/24 Mon
    • I sort of agree with both Rocket and Mark here but... -- colligwoodjo, 09:41 16/12/24 Mon
      • FWIW here' my preferred starting 18 -- Rocket surgeon, 10:46 16/12/24 Mon
        • You would think Perryman is likely to start. -- Josh, 10:59 16/12/24 Mon
          • Reckon Perryman and Crisp are center square mid rotations for us. -- collingwoodj, 11:16 16/12/24 Mon
            • Crispy mostly a winger in the gf. And just about best on ground. -- barcode, 16:47 17/12/24 Tue
              • Like those wings (NT) -- Flumpus, 18:34 18/12/24 Wed
              • He was 71 percent defensive half and got most of his footy across HB -- collingwoodj, 13:06 21/12/24 Sat
                • Crisp moved to half back after quarter time to replace Murphy, mentioned it -- Optimax, 15:38 21/12/24 Sat
                  • The coverage of the game mentioned markov went to half back rotation after QT (NT) -- Jen2310, 22:47 21/12/24 Sat
        • yeah but I expect that is becuase if you have 25 - 30 hardened AFL players... -- collingwoodj, 11:15 16/12/24 Mon
    • Not expecting Mick Turner and Ricky Barham on the wings -- Rocket surgeon, 10:16 16/12/24 Mon
      • Crisp seems such a natural obvious choice to play wing for us in 2025 (NT) -- Harry, 13:21 16/12/24 Mon
    • It is until a savvy coach tries it again and wins a flag then it will be in again. -- Rodda83, 20:18 16/12/24 Mon

  ---

• I'd go like this... -- Cakewalk, 11:20 16/12/24 Mon
  • Lippa did finish seventh in the Copeland -- Thommo, 13:15 16/12/24 Mon
    • Agree Thommo. -- Josh, 13:37 16/12/24 Mon
      • agree with this; ongoing issues with his foot (structural? /biomechnical?) not a good sign as you age -- sam-e, 15:39 16/12/24 Mon
  • You can slot lippa on the wing and HF. Josh D is back off half back. -- Jen2310, 14:41 16/12/24 Mon
    • Sidde seems the most interesting one IMO... -- Kaistar, 20:04 16/12/24 Mon
    • Membrey is depth -- Rizonico, 11:33 17/12/24 Tue
      • Membrey was offered a 2 year contract by the saints, he desisted himself -- Optimax, 12:47 17/12/24 Tue
      • Are you suggesting we go wtih Cox instead? Or no third tall? -- Cakewalk, 12:54 17/12/24 Tue
        • Agree Cakewalk. -- Josh, 16:53 17/12/24 Tue
          • I wouldn't be judicious having big Dan coming off an acl getting involved with more ruckwork -- Pyeman WPBD, 15:45 18/12/24 Wed
            • Fair point -- Cakewalk, 07:10 19/12/24 Thu
              • I reckon Cox is a better second ruck than McStay anyway and -- collingwoodj, 13:08 21/12/24 Sat
                • He is but he's not a better forward than Membrey -- Cakewalk, 17:53 21/12/24 Sat
        • So far nobody apart from the rucks have been doing ruck work -- Jen2310, 15:58 18/12/24 Wed
          • Pity Head Office didn't scrap the sub and just go with 5 on the bench... -- rooka..., 17:21 18/12/24 Wed
            • Agree, can't play them all -- Cakewalk, 07:09 19/12/24 Thu
              • Depends if we only play Moore and Howe as the tall backs -- Tim, 07:30 19/12/24 Thu
                • All our talls bar Darcy are over 30 now, yeah? -- Geek, 11:10 20/12/24 Fri
                  • Yep. Plus we could potentially swing membrey and brody back if needed (NT) -- Tim, 17:54 20/12/24 Fri
            • I agree, nobody likes the sub rules apart from the afl. -- Jen2310, 15:29 19/12/24 Thu
            • Rooka .. well said 5 main interchange would have helped Cox.. Membrey -- Pendles Boys, 21:15 21/12/24 Sat
          • That's good news (NT) -- Pyeman WPBD, 17:55 18/12/24 Wed
            • Which team other than Freo plays two rucks? -- Thommo, 12:31 20/12/24 Fri
              • The current depth of experienced players is excellent -- Rusty, 08:43 22/12/24 Sun
              • We'll need to play it by ear. -- JtP, 11:03 22/12/24 Sun