Create a New Forum Admin Login Member Login Contribute to Voyager Search VoyForums Help Desk VoyForums Exchange VoyForums Directory/Categories VoyForums Homepage VoyForums News FAQ - Frequently Asked Questions

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ]

• Bucks and Pendles are freaks for being consistently great.... -- Dino, 15:41 28/11/24 Thu
  • Buckley as a player was a tier above Pendles for impacting a game imo. -- Rodda83, 13:28 29/11/24 Fri
    • Agree Rodda. -- Josh, 13:31 29/11/24 Fri
      • He didn't get enough at the time either, imo -- Cakewalk, 19:09 29/11/24 Fri
        • Buckley was better then both without doubt. Bucks had inordinate amount of hate come his way (NT) -- Rodda83, 16:00 01/12/24 Sun
    • Pendles better at deliberately bringing team mates into the game -- Yo Gabbi Gabbi!, 14:38 29/11/24 Fri
      • Agree with above. Bucks more dynamic and brilliant. He was faster, -- Annabelle, 14:53 29/11/24 Fri
        • Agreed. Why Pendles will be -- Devious, 07:58 30/11/24 Sat
        • Degoey is a better physical comparison to Bucks -- Hiwire, 10:58 02/12/24 Mon
          • Buckley better then degoey for impact. People need to go rematch Buckley's games -- Rodda83, 00:10 06/12/24 Fri
            • Agreed. Short memories. Buckley dominated so often. -- Chicken wing, 14:26 06/12/24 Fri
            • No thanks. I was there for a lot of late 90s games -- Hiwire, 08:37 07/12/24 Sat
      • Bucks was the best field passer the game has ever seen. He brought others into play. (NT) -- muddy, 08:09 30/11/24 Sat
        • Arguably Pendles makes his teammates work harder in that regard -- Caklk, 12:34 30/11/24 Sat
          • Author should be Cakewalk above... My keyboard had a panic attack! (NT) -- Cakewalk, 12:45 30/11/24 Sat
          • The other thing about Bucks is that he was tagged for most of his career and coped well with this. (NT) -- Annabelle, 14:08 30/11/24 Sat
            • He rubbed blood on Ling's jumper, he didn't always cope with it (NT) -- Optimax, 15:51 30/11/24 Sat
              • Opti - its obvious you don't like or rate Bucks (NT) -- Alf, 18:33 30/11/24 Sat
                • This is where I think the coaching impacted. -- Josh, 07:04 01/12/24 Sun
                  • Buckley was the most tagged midfielf player the game has seen. And bar the odd one smashed them. -- Rodda83, 16:04 01/12/24 Sun
                • He systematically tore apart the greatest collingwood team we had seen -- Optimax, 08:14 01/12/24 Sun
                  • Surely his legacy as a player can be separated from his legacy as a coach. Also remember -- Annabelle, 10:41 01/12/24 Sun
                    • BTW Opti, was going to mention the Ling blood affair as the only blot on his escutheon when -- Annabelle, 10:44 01/12/24 Sun
                      • It didn't border on illegal it was illegal. He runs past the ball opposite side to Nathan to meet him -- Rodda83, 16:07 01/12/24 Sun
                    • Bucks was a magnificent player -- Pendlebury, 19:58 04/12/24 Wed
                      • That should read when he was a player he wasn't a very impressive man (NT) -- Pendlebury, 19:59 04/12/24 Wed
                  • "Bucks .. and likely was the reason behind not going back to back" -- sam-e, 11:03 01/12/24 Sun
                    • Bucks was an ordinary coach; Malthouse on the other hand was an ordinary human being! -- Crimson Mask, 15:55 01/12/24 Sun
                      • Mick had decent form in turning on players after a high profile loss -- sam-e, 21:20 01/12/24 Sun
                        • The players bar a few exceptions loved playing under Mick so let's not try to reinvent history -- Pyeman WPBD, 09:16 02/12/24 Mon
                          • Mick had decent form in turning on players after a high profile loss -- sam-e, 10:18 02/12/24 Mon
                    • I don't blame Mick or Bucks. -- Porter, 22:21 08/12/24 Sun
                  • So we exonerate Mick and Ed? -- BN, 11:07 01/12/24 Sun
                  • Tarnished legacy? Spare me. Bucks was, is and always will be one of Collingwood’s greatest -- barcode, 19:15 01/12/24 Sun
                  • Buckley -- Sereda, 21:48 01/12/24 Sun
                    • I'd say Geelong had a bit more to do with it than we give them credit for as well -- Cakewalk, 08:00 02/12/24 Mon
                      • Agree 100% Cakewalk. -- Josh, 08:24 02/12/24 Mon
                      • Spot on Cakewalk - they were better on the day(s) - that's it!! -- Two-Bob Man, 09:15 02/12/24 Mon
                        • So much is made of the positive effect Luke Ball made when he came across at the end of '09 -- Geek, 13:30 02/12/24 Mon
                      • I think thats a fact often overlooked..great point Cakewalk (NT) -- Mark W, 09:42 02/12/24 Mon
                      • Great post (NT) -- Genghis, 06:10 03/12/24 Tue
              • Ling ran past the ball no eyes on it and elbowed Buckley to the face. Often lost in this conversation -- Rodda83, 15:59 01/12/24 Sun
                • exactly this (NT) -- sam-e, 16:20 01/12/24 Sun
          • Your analysis is spot on. Pendles and Bucks are both great champions. -- muddy, 20:30 01/12/24 Sun
            • Pendles in both situations -- Pendlebury, 13:34 08/12/24 Sun